10 September 2019

Just what IS the Good News, which the Bible speaks of? - #Unitarian view based on Isaiah and Mark

At our gathering last Sunday we were led by the president for the day to consider change to be the source of our hope for the future.  This report is one response to what was presented.

After gathering words by Rev Dr Linda Hart, and prayer based on words from John D Caputo, we had two readings, a musical interlude, a time of silent meditation and a simple ritual for those who wanted it.  And we sang two hymns.

But for me, this time, it was the readings that made it a gathering to remember.



First, there was a short reading from the Old Testament of the Christian Bible, Book of Isaiah chapter 52 verses 7 to 15, starting with: ‘How beautiful on the mountains are the feet of those who bring good news, who proclaim peace, who bring good tidings, who proclaim salvation, who say to Zion: “Your God reigns!”’

And the second reading came from the New Testament of the Christian Bible, Book of Mark chapter 1 verses 1 to 15, ending with: ‘Jesus went into Galilee, proclaiming the good news of God.  “The time has come,” he said.  “The kingdom of God has come near.  Repent and believe the good news!”’

Now I was immediately engaged with this combination of readings. I have long been told that “gospel” means “good news”, but for me all sorts of churches have been very woolly about exactly what the good news is.  For the most part, churches seem to say that the arrival of Jesus himself was the good news.  But when reading the New Testament I feel short-changed on that.  Whilst Jesus speaks several times of the Good News, he did not ever say anything like that.  Verses in the New Testament are more along the lines of ‘Jesus and his disciples went around preaching the good news’, without actually saying what that good news is.  The closest I have ever got to understanding it is in the Book of Luke, chapter 10, in which Jesus gives instructions to his followers to go out and spread the message.  He says (verse 9) that they are to say to people that “the Kingdom of God has come near to you.”  And in a reinforcing teaching in Luke chapter 17 verses 20 and 21, Jesus says:

`20 Some Pharisees asked Jesus when the Kingdom of God would come. His answer was, “The Kingdom of God does not come in such a way as to be seen. 21 No one will say, ‘Look, here it is!' or, ‘There it is!'; because the Kingdom of God is within you.”’ 

What happened on Sunday was that at last someone was giving me a clear idea about what the good news actually is.  It felt to me that the idea being put to us was that the good news is about God, not about Jesus.  That Isaiah was saying that the good news is that God is in charge and will comfort ruined people and redeem the brokenness.  And that, moving forward in time, when Jesus was talking about spreading the good news, he was repeating the news of Isaiah - that God is in charge and will mend brokenness - but over and above what Isaiah said, what Jesus said was that actually there’s no special time nor place for that, because that action of God is available all the time, inside each person.

What our leader for the day has helpfully provided me, for this report, is this:

"Essentially: we are living in a world where bad things happen, unjust things, terrible things.  For all the good and the beauty that we see, there is a constant threat of it all coming to a sudden and sticky end. And that is all we have ever known.

Yet right there with that, there is a voice saying that this isn't the way it is meant to be. Right there with all the misery, there is that relentless call to make things better, to change ourselves and the world we live in.  Sometimes it is gentle and sometimes it roars in the thunder.

The Good News we are called to believe in, right here, right now, is that, despite all the evidence to the contrary, things can be better, we can be better; and that no matter how often we fall, how often we fail, we can get back up.

That call, to a place where the voice that demands better is heard and made real, is the Kingdom brought near.  

And experiencing change in ourselves, and believing in that Good News, is ‘that which we call God’ happening in us, and to us, and through us."


I’m really grateful for the connections of thought that we heard on Sunday.  Wisdom teachers through the ages have taught us that there is always a way back from knots and disorder, to order and peace.  And that the changes we may experience in ourselves as we travel that way back may often look and feel like behaviours of compassion, humility, renunciation and attentiveness; attentiveness to the needs of those around us as well as to our own.  But surely these come later: the first step is to act on what Jesus and others have said: to trust the Good News that “change is possible and that things can be made better.”




16 August 2019

#Unitarians encouraged to challenge and speak out during a heart-warming gathering in Ringwood

On 11th August we gathered as Unitarians and friends in the Meeting House in Ringwood, built in 1727, as we usually do on the second Sunday of each month.

Unitarians together in 2014 - in a setting similar to our gatherings
As we don’t have a Minister, all our services are led by one of us, who takes the lead without having had any special training.  We have found it very helpful to adopt a framework for our gatherings that originated at the Kensington congregation, and it is known as the “heart & soul” style service.

There’s a format provided - and with about an hour’s preparation, searching on the www for suitable prayers and words, and some more time with our green hymn book, finding hymns that we can sing because we know them, our leaders manage to curate very satisfactory experiences when we meet.  There’s an emphasis on collaborative engagement and participation to make the gathering work, so the format works well for small congregations that don’t have Ministers.

The theme on Sunday was the presenting of Unitarianism as the challenging of the accepted narrative and the daring to speak out when that narrative is found wanting.

The research by our president for the day had brought to light the story of St Oran, who was a follower of St Columba.  Oran had volunteered to be buried alive under the foundations of a new church being built by Columba, because it seemed that some form of sacrifice was required to stabilise the ground (the new building kept tumbling down while under construction).  But for some reason - perhaps this sacrifice was too much for Columba’s conscience - some days later, Columba ordered that Oran should be uncovered again.  And when he was uncovered, Oran shocked everyone by speaking, saying that there is no such great wonder in death, and that the descriptions of Heaven and Hell did not measure up.  He finished with a whisper to Columba, “The way you think it is may not be the way it is at all.”  At which point, Columba backtracked yet again and ordered Oran to be re-buried.  There’s still a saying in the Gaelic-speaking world which is used to silence uncomfortable subjects of conversation: “Throw mud in the mouth of St Oran.”

The children’s story that was read as the second reading was The Emperor’s New Clothes by Hans Christian Anderson.



The words of our second hymn included the words, “From honest doubt we shall not flee / Nor fetter the inquiring mind / For where the hearts of all are free / A truer faith we there shall find,” written by John Andrew Storey.

We had a secondary emphasis in our gathering of being committed to each other in community.  This was developed through a combination of music and words.  The music included our first hymn, which said, “ O let us live with humankind / As sisters, brothers, true / We’ll share our joys, our sorrows share / Becoming as we do,” written by Doris Jeanine Stevens. And there was a wonderfully relevant musical interlude in the form of a song by Ben Platt https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aDeNQNtW1f8  Grow As We Go

On the same theme of growing and committing in community, and sourced from the www, were the opening words from Rev Dr Linda Hart and chalice lighting words from Rev David Usher.

Everyone is welcome for the next gathering, which is on 8th September at 10 a.m.


(Early notice: there will be no gathering in November).

16 July 2019

Why #Unitarians say we do not all have to think alike to live kindly in the world

By Jarek Tuszyński
 / CC-BY-SA-3.0 & GDFL, CC BY-SA 3.0,
https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=4428255
Our gathering for reverence on 14 July was, as usual, a mixture of thoughts and experiences.  On a lovely summer’s morning, the activities we were invited to experience included:
  • remembering why we had been brought to the gathering
  • hymn singing to pre-recorded congregational singing
  • listening to recorded instrumental music
  • hearing and considering some quotes from key philosophers
  • passing in turn a flame, a feather fan, a plate of oaten biscuits, and a jug of water around the circle of people
  • listening to readings
  • discussing the meaning of the readings to us
  • hearing and/or participating privately in words of prayer or contemplation
  • holding seven minutes of silence for personal meditation
  • speaking thanks for special circumstances
  • voicing concerns for people known to us or wider world issues
  • lighting tea light candles
  • recognising children’s activities in the gathering

It’s amazing what variety can be fitted into the ‘heart and soul’ style of meeting that we have now adopted.

The topic that had been selected for the day was a comparison of two different ways of thinking or believing, each of which, if acted upon, will lead to compassionate behaviour.  The take home thought was that not all belief systems are the same and it is sloppy thinking to imagine that in general all religions and belief systems say the same thing; nonetheless the belief systems can all lead to the same outward signs and that these outward signs are what we should look for.

Understanding that it is the outward behaviour that matters most can be very helpful when dealing with and living amongst people who hold very different beliefs. 

~~~~~~~~~~

If you’re interested in what the readings were, which drew out this contrast, they were as follows.

The first was a children’s story from the Hindu tradition, which tells of the elephant-headed god Ganesha as a child, learning that if he hurt one creature he hurt all creatures and all creation, including himself; and this because his mother Parvati the Mother Goddess of the universe, lives in all creation.

The second reading came from the Northern Pagan tradition and it was a re-run of the reading from last month, about the tradition of wergild.  On a cosmic level the spiritual concept of wergild is that there is balance in the universe; so if one person wins, another loses, meaning that payment in compensation is due. “There are many ways to pay wergild, but you’ll know the right way.  It will resound in your soul, perhaps even in a way that makes your stomach sink.” (Northern Tradition for the Solitary Practitioner, Krasskova and Kaldera).

wergild was originally
payment made in gold coin
We were delighted that, without prior notice, a visitor from Oxford Unitarians joined us for this gathering.  And although, as it turns out, there were no children with us, should any have come, they would have been invited to show us their colouring-in of pictures of Ganesha in all his elephant-headed and pot-bellied glory.



As a last point, as nearby in Bournemouth this weekend was the gay pride celebration "Bourne Free", we decked the entrance to the Meeting House in the rainbow flag of Pride.